Skip to content
image of woman looking at man very hopeful
FitOn HealthApril 05

Pros and Cons of Profit-Based Care for Employees

In the United States, Profit-Based Care is an employee healthcare plan in which the financial company's financial performance determines an employer's contribution to the employee's healthcare coverage. In other words, if the company is profitable, the employee's health care coverage is more comprehensive. The employee's health care coverage is less extensive if the company is not. While this type of healthcare plan may seem beneficial to the company's financial performance, it has pros and cons for employees.

Pros of Profit-Based Care

  • Cost Savings: One of the main advantages of Profit-Based Care is cost savings for the employer. In this model, employer coverage for health care services happens when the company is profitable. This can result in significant cost savings for employers, especially when the company is underperforming.
  • Incentivizes Company Growth: Profit-Based Care incentivizes company growth and success. If employees know that their healthcare coverage is directly linked to the company's success, they may be more motivated to work hard and contribute to its success. This can create a more productive and engaged workforce.
  • Provides Flexibility: Profit-Based Care offers flexibility for employers regarding health care coverage. If the company is not profitable, the employer can reduce health care coverage, which can help the company stay afloat during difficult times.
  • Encourages Employee Wellness: Profit-Based Care can promote employee wellness by incentivizing employees to adopt healthier lifestyles. If employees know their healthcare coverage is linked to the company's financial success, they may be more motivated to maintain good health and wellness habits.
  • Community Benefit: Under the Profit-Based Care model, employees can still take advantage of charity care options like nonprofit hospitals. Charitable organizations own nonprofit hospitals, and their primary goal is to provide health care services to the community.

Cons of Profit-Based Care

  • Uncertainty: One of the main disadvantages of Profit-Based Care is its uncertainty for employees. If employees are unsure about the level of health insurance that they will receive, it can create anxiety and stress. In addition, employees may also be concerned about company profitability's impact on their health coverage.
  • Inequity: Profit-Based Care can create inequity among employees. If some employees receive more comprehensive health insurance coverage than others based on the company's financial performance, it can create resentment and conflict among employees. Those who require family coverage may be at a greater disadvantage if companies underperform.
  • Lack of Control: Employees have little control over their health care coverage under Profit-Based Care. If the company is not profitable, employees may have to accept reduced health care coverage, regardless of their health needs. They also lack access to medical records, which may be crucial to treating chronic illnesses.
  • Reduced Benefits: Profit-Based Care can lead to reduced employee healthcare for, example, supposed benefits. If the company is not profitable, the employer may reduce healthcare benefits to save costs, negatively impacting employee health and wellness.

Effect on Employee Wellness Programs

Profit-based care models can positively and negatively affect employee wellness programs. Profit-based care models may incentivize employers to invest in an employee wellness program or health plan and reduce individual costs. If employees are proactive about their health, they may require less medical care, leading to lower healthcare costs for the employer.

However, profit-based care models may also negatively affect employee wellness programs. If the employer's financial performance is weak, they may be less likely to invest in employee wellness programs or reduce the scope of the programs to cut costs. This could minimize employee resources to improve their health and wellness, negatively impacting their health outcomes and overall well-being.

Profit-based care models may create uncertainty and stress for employees, which could lead to decreased participation in wellness programs. Employees may become concerned about losing their healthcare coverage or their financial stability due to the employer's performance. In that case, they may be less likely to participate in wellness programs, which could negatively impact their health and well-being.

To mitigate these potential negative effects, employers can consider offering health benefits in the form of wellness programs that are not linked to the company's financial performance. This would provide employees with greater certainty about the availability of wellness resources and could help to prevent negative impacts on employee health and well-being.

Effect on Employee Morale

Profit-Based Care can have positive and negative effects on employee morale, but the most important aspect to its success is transparency.  To mitigate potential negative impacts, employers should communicate transparently with employees about the company's financial performance and the impact on healthcare coverage. This can help to alleviate employee uncertainty and anxiety and can help to foster a sense of trust and collaboration between employers and employees. Employers should also ensure that primary care options are provided equitably among all employees, regardless of the company's financial performance.

Overall, the impact of profit-based care models on employee morale will depend on various factors, including the employer's financial performance, the transparency and communication from employers, and the overall culture and priorities of the organization. Employers should carefully consider these factors and work to ensure that employee morale is supported and maintained, even during financial uncertainty.

Alternatives to Profit-Based Care

There are several alternatives to Profit-Based Care that employers can consider. But it is important to note that the success of an employee healthcare model can vary based on the industry, company size, and other factors. However, recent studies and trends show that some models have succeeded more than others.

One successful model is the fixed contribution model, in which the employer contributes a fixed amount of money towards the employee's health care coverage, and the employee is responsible for the remaining costs. This model gives employees more control over their healthcare coverage and encourages them to choose a plan that meets their needs.

Another successful model is the value-based care model, which focuses on improving the quality of care while reducing costs. In this model, healthcare providers are incentivized to provide high-quality care that leads to better patient health outcomes, which can ultimately reduce overall health care costs.

Finally, the outcome-based model is also gaining popularity as the healthcare performance-based model. This model incentivizes healthcare providers to achieve specific health outcomes, such as reducing hospital readmissions or improving patient satisfaction. This model can improve employee health outcomes while reducing healthcare costs for employers and employees.

Ultimately, the most successful model of employee health care will depend on each company's specific needs and goals. Therefore, it is essential for employers to carefully consider the options and choose a model that provides the best healthcare coverage and support for their employees.


While profit-Based Care can incentivize employees to work harder and contribute to the company's financial success, it can also create uncertainty and anxiety for employees. Employers should greatly consider the pros and cons of Profit-Based Care for employees before implementing it as a healthcare plan. Alternatives to Profit-Based Care, such as fixed or flexible health care plans and wellness programs not linked to the company's financial performance, can better support employee morale during stressful periods or when a company underperforms. And by considering these alternatives, employers support their employees' need to stay healthy, happy, and productive.

Never miss a beat