When a client's workforce is shift-based or distributed, the wellness benefit conversation should center on utilization, not plan design. Brokers create the most value by asking how many employees use the benefit month over month, then connecting any gap to access barriers like desktop-only portals, live-only content, and email-based communication that a shift-based or distributed team can't realistically use.
For many organizations, frontline and deskless employees aren’t a small subset of the workforce. They make up a significant — and often majority — share of the people they employ. That means benefits designed around a traditional 9-to-5, desk-based experience may not work for the people who need them most.
Related: How Wellness Programs Foster Employee Loyalty and Reduce Turnover
Why wellness benefits for shift-based teams need a different broker conversation
A wellness benefit built for a desk-based team will structurally underperform for a shift-based or distributed one, and renewal data is starting to make that gap visible to clients.
Three forces are driving this conversation into more renewal and prospecting meetings right now:
1. Renewal scrutiny has increased
Clients are asking harder questions about every benefit line, and utilization data is becoming the standard they judge a vendor against.
Related: Good Utilization Rate for Wellness Benefits: 8 Tips to Raise It
2. Access barriers are well documented
Limited computer access during the workday is the top barrier HR professionals cite when communicating benefits to deskless employees, according to SHRM and Fidelity Investments research. As a result, 61% of HR professionals report that deskless workers primarily learn about benefits information through their personal cellphone.
3. The ROI case is easier to make than it used to be
Research by FitOn Health and Havarti Risk found that employers with lifestyle-focused preventive care programs see a 3.6x ROI and $359 in healthcare savings per engaged employee per year, but only when the program is designed around the right utilization data.
The client who says "our wellness benefit isn't performing" is very often a client whose workforce structure was never factored into the original benefit design.
What clients get wrong about wellness benefits for deskless employees
Most clients are evaluating the wrong number. Enrollment tells you who signed up. It says nothing about who is actually opening the app each month. That’s the number that tells you whether a benefit is truly becoming part of employees’ routines.
The following patterns show up again and again:
- They're looking at enrollment, not usage. A high sign-up rate can sit next to a low active-usage rate without anyone noticing until renewal.
- They assume one communication plan covers everyone. A single open enrollment email works for a desk-based team and misses a shift-based one almost entirely.
- They picked a benefit built for a knowledge worker. Live-only classes, desktop portals, and single sign-on through a work email all quietly exclude employees who don't sit at a computer.
- They haven't segmented the data. Utilization broken out by department, location, or role usually tells a very different story than the topline number.
Related: How to Offer Wellness Benefits When Your Team Isn't at a Desk
Questions brokers should ask about shift-based workforce wellness benefits
Ask about usage before you talk about plan design. These five questions move a client from defending their current vendor to seeing the actual gap in their benefit's reach:
- What percentage of your workforce is shift-based, hourly, or without a company email address?
- Are you looking at enrollment or monthly active usage when you evaluate this benefit?
- How does your current benefit get communicated to someone who isn't checking a work inbox?
- If you segmented utilization by location or department, what would you expect to find?
- What would it mean for your renewal conversation next year if utilization among your frontline team doubled?
That last question is usually the one that gets people thinking. It moves the conversation from defending the current vendor to asking what could actually work better.
Related: Top Wellness Strategies for Hybrid Teams
Client conversation scripts for shift-based and distributed team wellness benefits
Use these lines close to verbatim in a renewal meeting, prospecting call, or follow-up email.
-
Opening the conversation at renewal: "Before we talk about next year's plan, I want to look at usage, not just enrollment. If a meaningful part of your team isn't using this benefit, that's worth understanding before we renew it as is."
-
When a client says utilization looks fine overall: "Topline usage can look healthy while masking a real gap. Can we break this down by location or role? I'd expect usage to look different for your corporate team versus your shift-based locations, and that gap is usually where the opportunity is."
-
When a client is skeptical that a wellness benefit can work for a deskless team: "The barrier usually isn't interest, it's access. If the benefit requires a desktop login or only offers live classes during business hours, it was built for a desk-based employee."
-
When positioning a new benefit to a prospective client: "Whether your team is a single site or spread across the country, remote, hybrid, or distributed, it is one platform your whole workforce can actually use, no matter where your people show up."
-
When a client raises cost concerns: “The question isn’t just what a benefit costs. It’s whether employees are actually using it and getting value from it. Sometimes the biggest opportunity isn’t adding another benefit — it’s making sure the benefits you’re investing in are working harder.”
What to recommend for shift-based and distributed workforce wellness benefits
Once the conversation has shifted to access and utilization, walk the client toward a benefit built around five things:
- Mobile-first delivery over desktop-first. Employees should be able to access everything from their phone, on their own time.
- On-demand content, not just live classes. Shift-based employees need workouts, nutrition and health courses, and stress support available whenever their shift allows, not on a fixed schedule.
- Communication that doesn't rely on a work inbox. Text, break room signage, QR codes, and manager-led rollout consistently outperform an all-company email for this population.
- A single platform instead of point solutions. Premium workouts, nutrition and health courses, and the largest variety of in-person experiences under one benefit is easier to communicate, administer, and measure than several disconnected vendors.
- Utilization reporting the client can act on. Monthly, segmented usage data gives you something concrete to bring into the next renewal conversation.
Your clients don't all serve the same kind of workforce. Their wellness benefit strategy shouldn't assume they do. See FitOn Health in action by signing up for our next Demo Day, a live 30-minute walkthrough of the platform.
